MPs to debate petitions relating to university tuition fees

On Monday 16 November, MPs will debate e-petitions relating to university tuition fees. Chris Evans MP (Islwyn), member of the Petitions Committee, will lead the debate. The Department for Education will send a Minister to respond.

Require universities to reimburse students’ tuition fees during strike action

The petition, which has more than 136,000 signatures, states: “The University and College Union has repeatedly called on its members to strike. However, strikes are ineffective if students, not employees are the main source of revenue. For this to change, government needs to step in and require universities to reimburse tuition fees lost due to strike action.”

In response to the petition, the Government said: “Strike action is a matter for Universities to address, not Government. We expect universities to make efforts to replace lost learning or financial compensation if appropriate.”

Reimburse all students of this year’s fees due to strikes and COVID-19

The petition, which has more than 353,000 signatures, states: “All students should be reimbursed of this years tuition fees as universities are now online only due to COVID-19, with only powerpoints online for learning materials which is not worthy of up to £9,250. Furthermore, all assessments are being reconsidered to ‘make do’ and build up credits.”

In response to the petition, the Government said: “HE providers must deliver high quality courses.

If students are unhappy they should first complain to their provider and if their concerns are unresolved they can ask OIA to consider their complaint.”

Refund university students for 3rd Semester Tuition 2020

The petition, which has more than 111,000 signatures, states: “As students are unable to access facilities or continue with their education at their university setting in the following semester, we would like to request that the government considers refunding tuition payments for Semester 3.”

In response to the petition, the Government said: “HE providers must deliver high quality courses.

If students are unhappy they should first complain to their provider and if their concerns are unresolved they can ask OIA to consider their complaint.”

Require universities to partially refund tuition fees for 20/21 due to Covid-19

The petition, which has more than 218,000 signatures, states: “The quality of online lectures is not equal to face-to-face lectures. Students should not have to pay full tuition fees for online lectures, without experiencing university life. The Government should require UK universities to partially refund tuition fees while online teaching is.”

In response to the petition, the Government said: “Higher education providers must deliver high-quality courses. If students are unhappy, they should first complain to their provider, or the Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education.”

Lower university tuition fees for students until online teaching ends

The petition, which has more than 164,000 signatures, states: “As the Coronavirus escalates, there are concerns that a trade deal between the UK Government and the US deal might not exempt our NHS, leaving it vulnerable to privatisation and in direct contradiction to promises this would not happen.”

In response to the petition, the Government said: “The government has been clear that protecting the UK’s right to regulate in the public interest and protecting public services, including the NHS, is of the upmost importance.”

The debate follows the publication of the Committee’s report on this issue in July, which quickly became one of the most read select committee reports of the last 10 years. The report called on the Government to take urgent action and review the support for universities and students in the face of the “greatest challenge they have faced for generations”.

The report followed an inquiry where tens of thousands of students raised concerns that they had not received a reasonable standard of education due to Coronavirus. During the investigation, the Committee also heard evidence on how the outbreak has impacted in particular those from disadvantaged backgrounds, and those on more hands-on courses where students need to use university facilities.

In its response to the report, the Government accepted that students should be able to take action if they are unsatisfied with their university’s response to the pandemic. However, the Government rejected the Committee’s recommendation for a new centralised system which enables all students to easily seek a full or partial refund of their tuition fees, or to repeat part of their course.

The debate will last 90 minutes, and will provide opportunities for MPs to question Government Ministers directly on these issues. The debate will take place in Westminster Hall from 18:00, and will be available to view onParliament TV.

Petition details

• ‘Require universities to reimburse students’ tuition fees during strike action’ – view on petition signature map.
• ‘Reimburse all students of this year’s fees due to strikes and COVID-19’ – view on petition signature map.
• ‘Refund university students for 3rd Semester Tuition 2020’ – view on petition signature map.
• ‘Require universities to partially refund tuition fees for 20/21 due to Covid-19’ – view on petition signature map.
• ‘Lower university tuition fees for students until online teaching ends’ – view on petition signature map.
• Any Library Briefing Papers for this debate will be available here.

Follow the debate:

• Watch the debate live online: https://parliamentlive.tv/Commons or https://youtu.be/5n7QzDAmzck
• Read the debate transcript: https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2020-11-16   
• Follow the Committee on Twitter: https://twitter.com/hocpetitions
• You can also follow the debate with the hashtag: #TuitionFeesDebate

Where in the country were these petitions signed?

The top 10 parliamentary constituencies that supported the petition ‘Require universities to reimburse students’ tuition fees during strike action’ are as follows (as at 10 November 2020):

Constituency	MP	Signature Count
Sheffield Central	Paul Blomfield MP	2028
Brighton, Pavilion	Caroline Lucas MP	1990
Bristol West	Thangam Debbonaire MP	1652
Manchester Central	Lucy Powell MP	1532
Liverpool, Riverside	Kim Johnson MP	1419
Cardiff Central	Jo Stevens MP	1353
Leeds Central	Rt Hon Hilary Benn MP	1335
Bath	Wera Hobhouse MP	1332
City of Durham	Mary Kelly Foy MP	1222
Nottingham South	Lilian Greenwood MP	1170

The top 10 parliamentary constituencies that supported the petition ‘Reimburse all students of this year’s fees due to strikes and COVID-19’ are as follows (as at 10 November 2020):

Constituency	MP	Signature Count
Brighton, Pavilion	Caroline Lucas MP	3067
Sheffield Central	Paul Blomfield MP	3005
Manchester Central	Lucy Powell MP	2796
Holborn and St Pancras	Rt Hon Keir Starmer MP	2744
Leeds Central	Rt Hon Hilary Benn MP	2591
Coventry South	Zarah Sultana MP	2482
Bethnal Green and Bow	Rushanara Ali MP	2440
Nottingham South	Lilian Greenwood MP	2295
Bristol West	Thangam Debbonaire MP	2145
West Ham	Ms Lyn Brown MP	2110

The top 10 parliamentary constituencies that supported the petition ‘Refund university students for 3rd Semester Tuition 2020’ are as follows (as at 10 November 2020):

Constituency	MP	Signature Count
Sheffield Central	Paul Blomfield MP	1290
Manchester Central	Lucy Powell MP	903
Holborn and St Pancras	Rt Hon Keir Starmer MP	731
Cardiff Central	Jo Stevens MP	729
Bristol West	Thangam Debbonaire MP	703
Brighton, Pavilion	Caroline Lucas MP	674
Nottingham South	Lilian Greenwood MP	629
Colchester	Will Quince MP	540
Bath	Wera Hobhouse MP	525
Plymouth, Sutton and Devonport	Luke Pollard MP	515

The top 10 parliamentary constituencies that supported the petition ‘Require universities to partially refund tuition fees for 20/21 due to Covid-19’ are as follows (as at 10 November 2020):

Constituency	MP	Signature Count
Manchester Central	Lucy Powell MP	1360
Newcastle upon Tyne East	Rt Hon Nicholas Brown MP	1176
Leeds Central	Rt Hon Hilary Benn MP	1146
Leeds North West	Alex Sobel MP	1131
Sheffield Central	Paul Blomfield MP	1027
Portsmouth South	Stephen Morgan MP	1008
Liverpool, Riverside	Kim Johnson MP	945
Brighton, Pavilion	Caroline Lucas MP	891
Manchester, Gorton	Afzal Khan MP	883
West Ham	Ms Lyn Brown MP	869

The top 10 parliamentary constituencies that supported the petition ‘Lower university tuition fees for students until online teaching ends’ are as follows (as at 10 November 2020):

Constituency	MP	Signature Count
Liverpool, Riverside	Kim Johnson MP	1830
Brighton, Pavilion	Caroline Lucas MP	1630
Nottingham South	Lilian Greenwood MP	1621
Bristol West	Thangam Debbonaire MP	1557
Leeds Central	Rt Hon Hilary Benn MP	1437
Manchester Central	Lucy Powell MP	1353
Nottingham East	Nadia Whittome MP	1319
Sheffield Central	Paul Blomfield MP	1289
Newcastle upon Tyne East	Rt Hon Nicholas Brown MP	1286
Holborn and St Pancras	Rt Hon Keir Starmer MP	1066