Research published today (28 Jan) by the Royal Academy of Engineering indicates that the gender pay gap is smaller in the engineering profession than the UK employee average. The mean (10.8%) and median (11.4%) pay gap for engineers in the sample analysed is around two thirds the national average.
Although the gap is less than feared, the report finds that closing it will take concerted effort within the engineering profession.
One well-recognised issue that is contributing to the gender pay gap in engineering is the lack of women going into the profession, and while attempts have been made to address this, progress is disappointingly slow.
The report recommends actions that go beyond addressing this initial recruitment challenge to close the gender pay gap through addressing the retention and progression of women to more senior and higher paid roles. The actions it recommends as most effective include implementing transparent pay structures and grades, reviewing promotion criteria and introducing flexible working options for senior roles.
To compile Closing the engineering gender pay gap, the first report of its kind for the engineering profession, the Academy commissioned WISE to analyse the pay data of nearly 42,000 engineers working in the UK, to approximate the gender pay gap for the engineering profession. This analysis, with data voluntarily provided by 25 engineering organisations of different sizes and from different sectors, excludes non-engineering roles to help identify issues and challenges specific to the profession. This approach differs from the mandatory gender pay gap reporting to government, which does not identify the professions of individuals in an organisation.
The report confirms that underrepresentation of women in senior roles - rather than unequal pay - is the single largest cause of the gender pay gap for engineers. The factors that most contributed to pay variance for engineers in the sample included career level (40%), type of employer (12%), age (6%) and the annual revenue of the employer (5%). Just 9% of engineers in the top career grade in the sample were female and women accounted for only 8% of those in the upper pay quartile.
Jonathan Lyle CB FREng, Chair of the Academy’s Closing the gender pay gap Steering Group, said:
“Reducing both gender and race inequality is key to addressing the damaging shortage of engineering skills in the UK economy. Whilst we are making some modest progress in attracting more girls and women into engineering, our research shows that there remains much to be done to achieve gender equality in engineering careers.
“The good news is that there are well proven steps that business leaders can and should take to improve how women engineers progress within their companies into more senior, more influential, more fulfilling, better rewarded roles. The best, most inclusive, businesses are doing this well, critically underpinning their business success. But others make excuses about their gender pay gap, risking losing business and talent.”
Helen Wollaston, WISE Chief Executive said:
“This isn’t really about pay, and it isn’t really about women. It’s about good business. Our research found that a credible action plan to address the underlying causes of the gender pay gap helps recruit the best people, engage and motivate your employees and gives a competitive edge when bidding for contracts from public sector clients. The recommendations are relevant to engineering employers of all sizes, whether or not they have to publish a gender pay gap report.”
Closing the Engineering Gender Pay Gap
28th May 2019: The Royal Academy of Engineering commissioned Women into Science and Engineering (WISE) to quantify the gender pay gap for engineers in the UK, identify the underlying causes and recommend effective solutions. This research project is a key element of the Academy’s diversity and inclusion strategy, which aligns closely with WISE’s core purpose of achieving gender balance in science, technology and engineering.
This research aims to:
- build the first dataset of quantified data specific to engineering roles
- look at the underlying reasons for a gender pay gapin engineering
- make practical recommendationsand an action plan on how the gap can be closed
WISE is currently seeking participants in the research that will underpin this project and would be interested to hear from engineering organisations in the UK. The research has two elements, quantitative and qualitative:
WISE is looking for companies willing to provide a sub-set of their gender pay gap data for people employed in engineering roles.
Deadline for submission – 30th June 2019
We will use this data to calculate and analyse the gender pay gap for engineers, comparing the situation for engineers in different sectors.
We are looking for individuals from organisations that employ engineers to join a focus group to discuss their personal and professional experiences.
There will be one focus group, held in central London, for each of the following groups of professionals:
- 26 June 2019 (AM): HR / Reward representatives
- 26 June 2019 (PM): Female engineers
- 02 July 2019 (AM): Male engineers
- 02 July 2019 (PM): Diversity & Inclusion representatives (either in a full-time role or as sponsors of D&I for your company)
Why get involved?
By signing up to participate in this key research project, you can:
- participate in a project that will be the first to deliver evidence and narrative on the engineering gender pay gap.
- be part of the first collectively developed action plan to close the gender pay gap in engineering
- Contribute towards genuine and sustainable change
Be part of the change we need to make engineering a sector where everybody, whatever their gender, can make the best use of their abilities.
The Gender Pay Gap vs Equal Pay. The gender pay gap is the difference in average hourly earnings for all men and all women across an organisation, a sector, or the economy as a whole. It is an indicator of gender parity within a workforce; the more men in senior positions or in roles with higher pay in an organisation, the larger the gender pay gap. It is different to equal pay which is paying men and women the same salary for the same (or similar) work. Unequal pay has been unlawful since 1970.