CAREERS ADVICE IN SCHOOLS FAILING PUPILS – NEW REPORT BY INDUSTRY APPRENTICES
The ‘world’s best career route’ at risk from poor policy and government changes
Despite successive governments having created what apprentices say could be ‘the best career route in the world’ for under-25s, apprentices say this is now at risk.
New research shows 98 per cent of engineering apprentices are happy in their jobs – citing good pay and no debt, fulfilling work, qualifications and career progression. But this extraordinarily successful career route is at risk from government changes to the apprenticeship system and is being held back by poor careers advice at school.
The research was carried out with 1200 apprentices, through the Industry Apprentice Council – made up of apprentices from the advanced manufacturing and engineering sector and supported by national engineering skills body Semta.
Ann Watson, chief executive of the Semta Group, said: “As we finalise new standards for apprenticeships it is important that ministers listen to apprentices and prevent the collapse of an extremely successful system. We are already facing an uphill battle with poor careers advice in schools. We need to make apprenticeships more attractive not less to our young people and employers, particularly the SMEs, at a time when we need all the engineers we can get and the skills gap is growing – we need nearly two million more engineers and technical staff by 2025.”
92 per cent of the apprentices surveyed oppose the removal of mandatory qualifications by the Department for Education with warnings that this risks creating a two tier system. Those studying the new T-Levels will achieve a recognised formal qualification while apprentices may not – as qualifications are not mandatory in the new apprenticeship standards.
John Coombes, IAC member and toolmaker at Ford Motor Company Ltd, said: “Governments have created what must be the world’s best career route for young people – where else would we get 98% saying they are happy with their career choice? But more than 90 per cent of apprentices oppose the removal of mandated qualifications, and there is a lot of unease about the focus on the End Point Assessment as the primary measure of an apprentice’s achievement.”
Careers advice was highly criticised by the apprentices. Only 22 per cent received good or very good advice from schools, with 5 per cent receiving no advice and nearly 40 per cent saying their advice was bad or very bad.
The research also highlighted a significant gender bias in careers advice, with 85 per cent of female apprentices saying their school or college had put higher education as the number one option for school leavers, compared to just 77 per cent for male apprentices. Similarly fewer young women were given information about apprenticeships compared to young men – 35 per cent against 41 per cent.
Philippa Dressler-Pearson, IAC member and advanced technical engineering apprentice at Southco Manufacturing Ltd, Worcester, said: “There’s a massive skills shortage of engineers and technical staff in the UK but you don’t hear anything about this in schools. Teachers don’t have enough information about apprenticeships, why they are important and what they offer.”
The apprentices have made a number of recommendations for government and schools. They say no school should be awarded outstanding by OFSTED unless they deliver quality careers advice on apprenticeships and that this advice should be a statutory requirement in all schools. They also want formal qualifications included in apprenticeship standards wherever employers recommend them.
The Industry Apprentice Council, set up by Semta, is the UK’s industry voice for apprentices and recognised by government – members are regularly invited to address MPs, peers and leaders in education and industry.
IAC research findings
- Full results from the IAC survey are available on request
- 98% of 1198 respondents said they were pleased their choice to take up an apprenticeship
- The important elements that influenced their careers choice were
o Earning while learning (82%)
o Career prospects (76%)
o Having a formal qualification (73%)
o Practical learning (64%)
o Avoiding debt (57%)
- The number of respondents saying that schools recommended apprenticeships as an option to pupils fell from 42% in 2016 to 40% in 2017
- More respondents ranked the careers information, advice and guidance at their school or college to be poor, up from 22% in 2016 to 23% in 2017. 15% ranked their advice very poor, up from 14% in 2016
- 88% of respondents do not agree that all apprentices should be assessed through End Point Assessment.
- Only 8% of respondents say that formal qualifications should not be required as part of an apprenticeship
About Semta: Semta works for and on behalf of employers, creating skilled engineers for the future.
It ensures engineering and manufacturing employers have the skills they need by influencing government policy; helping fill the skills gap; and advising employers on recruiting, training and assessing apprentices.
Semta is a charitable body with three trading divisions; EAL for assessments, Semta Apprenticeship Service for managing and delivering apprenticeships, and Semta International, taking the UK skills quality brand around the world. Profits are reinvested in skills development for the future in areas such as research, policy advice, skills awards and helping employers anticipate engineering skills trends.
Semta strongly promotes the value of diversity and equality in engineering, particularly in apprenticeships. It launched the apprenticeship toolkit in June 2017 to help employers and training organisations recruit, retain and promote more female apprentices. Its annual Semta Skills Awards includes recognition for the best female apprentice.
About The Industry Apprentice Council (IAC): The IAC is the UK’s industry voice for apprentices and the wider further education sector. Founded and supported by Semta Group, the IAC is made up of young apprentices predominantly from the advanced manufacturing and engineering sector throughout the UK.
It is recognised by government as an important part of the apprenticeship debate, with members regularly invited to address MPs, peers and leaders in both industry and education.
All members of the IAC are passionate and have their own stories as to why they followed the apprenticeship path. They regularly share them at careers fairs, in schools and through the media to inspire the next generation to consider apprenticeships
Responses